The story
Sirius Pizza has touched down at 27 Prince Street with a sleek, modern vibe and a 4.4-star rating, offering a fresh take on the New York slice with Italian inflections. Jack's Dining Room calls it "some of the best pizza I've ever had," noting the "incredible dough and toppings." He specifically recommends the Indua Sausage Pizza and the Mushroom Pie, both earning his thumbs up.
The main drawback? High prices. For now, this polished newcomer is a compelling downtown option, though you'll pay a premium for those excellent pies.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2025.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 2 dish mentions say about the food
Jack's Dining Room calls Sirius Pizza's mushroom pie a standout, praising its earthy depth and flaky crust. The overall vibe is one of humble, satisfying comfort food executed with care.
“Every slice I've bowed, zero flop. Oh my god, this is unbelievable. This is my favorite slice, honestly. I think by far, I've never tasted pizza like this in my life. It's almost like a fondue cheese and the mushrooms and the onions together are incredible. Kind of gives that like French onion soup flavor on pizza. It's been a long time since a slice of pizza has made me feel this way. Serious did it. They moved me.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Sirius Pizza. Most active: Jack's Dining Room
Sirius Pizza serves some of the best pizza I've ever had, with incredible dough and toppings, though the high prices are a downside.
Dishes mentioned
Indua Sausage Pizza
Right off the bat, you got the burnt edges, and it's like a stealth bomber coming out of the oven. This is some of the better quality dough I've had in a pizza. Perfectly light and crispy. And this burrata is like just straight milk in a good way. Low key, the only thing to hate about this pie is the price. Besides that, it's fucking delicious.
Mushroom Pie
Every slice I've bowed, zero flop. Oh my god, this is unbelievable. This is my favorite slice, honestly. I think by far, I've never tasted pizza like this in my life. It's almost like a fondue cheese and the mushrooms and the onions together are incredible. Kind of gives that like French onion soup flavor on pizza. It's been a long time since a slice of pizza has made me feel this way. Serious did it. They moved me.
