The story
Located on 8th Avenue, Shake Shack remains a staple for those seeking a quintessential New York burger experience. The venue maintains a solid reputation, with creator Bertra praising the chain for serving one of the best smash burgers he has ever encountered, specifically highlighting the juicy, balanced, and hot quality of the Bacon Cheeseburger. For those with a sweet tooth, the Dubai Chocolate Shake is also noted as a must-try menu item.
While the brand generally holds a high standard, experiences can vary depending on the location. Giovanni Fois noted that while Shake Shack is a reliable choice, his experience with a pre-prepped SmokeShack at the Citi Field location felt slightly dry. Despite this, the restaurant continues to be a go-to destination for fans of classic American fast-casual fare in the heart of the city.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2022.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 3 dish mentions say about the food
The Smokeshack burger earns raves for its smoky, juicy perfection, while the overall vibe is one of indulgent, no-fuss satisfaction that keeps crowds coming back.
“This is the most famous and supposedly the best one. I asked them to remove the cherry peppers because I don't like them, but they didn't take them off. It's good because it's Shake Shack, but you can tell these were prepped a while ago — the bottom bun is dry, the meat is a bit dry, even the bacon has dried out. Normally Shake Shack is a 9 out of 10, this is like a 7. It's good, but dry.”
What creators say
2 creators have covered Shake Shack. Most active: Giovanni Fois, Bertra
Shake Shack at Citi Field is a solid burger spot, but the pre-prepped SmokeShack was a bit dry compared to the usual high standard.
Dishes mentioned
SmokeShack
This is the most famous and supposedly the best one. I asked them to remove the cherry peppers because I don't like them, but they didn't take them off. It's good because it's Shake Shack, but you can tell these were prepped a while ago — the bottom bun is dry, the meat is a bit dry, even the bacon has dried out. Normally Shake Shack is a 9 out of 10, this is like a 7. It's good, but dry.
Shake Shack serves one of the best Smash Burgers I've ever had — juicy, balanced, and hot — and their shakes are a must-try.
Dishes mentioned
- Cheeseburger
Dubai Chocolate Shake
I thought it would be disgusting, but it's actually the best version of Dubai Chocolate I've ever tasted. The chocolate is solid at first but then it's good. The pistachio flavor is great. If you go to Shake Shack, you have to get a shake — it's their strong point, that's why it's called Shake Shack.
