The story
Restaurant Atletico is a bustling seafood destination in Horta, drawing crowds for its generous plates of lapas and shrimp drenched in garlic and coriander. Reservations are essential, or expect to queue—the place is perpetually busy. Sentieri Golosi praised the abundant, vibrant vibe but had mixed feelings: “I loved the vibe but hated the coriander,” he noted, and found the coffee tragically terrible. The grilled octopus with vegetables and fish-and-rice soup also stand out on the menu. For seafood lovers who don’t mind herbs, it’s a local spot worth the wait, but coffee drinkers may want to look elsewhere for their fix.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2024.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 5 dish mentions say about the food
Reviewers praise Restaurant Atletico’s Lapas as a standout, with the overall vibe being warm and unpretentious, celebrating simple, coastal flavors.
“These limpets are very calloused, so you chew them a lot. They added a touch of garlic, they're quite sweet, good. But there's a problem: damn coriander. I want a coriander-free island please.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Restaurant Atletico. Most active: Sentieri Golosi
A very busy restaurant in Horta where you need to book in advance or queue, serving abundant seafood dishes with lots of garlic and coriander — I loved the vibe but hated the coriander and the terrible coffee.
Dishes mentioned
Lapas
These limpets are very calloused, so you chew them a lot. They added a touch of garlic, they're quite sweet, good. But there's a problem: damn coriander. I want a coriander-free island please.
Gamberi con Aglio e Coriandolo
Very, very prawn with garlic and coriander again. I like it a lot. But there's a lot of smoking, which I think covers the flavor a bit. Still nice fat, good health.
Polpo alla Griglia con Verdure
Grilled octopus with a little vegetables. This octopus is very different, it tastes like chorizo. Dad was probably an octopus, mum was a choriza, they did fiky fiky and made this chorizated octopus. The vegetables? Maybe chicory? Spinach? No, nothing we know. Good but not great.
Zuppa di Pesce con Riso
I had fish soup with rice. I knew rice even without rice is good. Oh no, not without rice it's good, without rice it's good. Very interesting dish. It's called Ukha, but without rice.
Caffè
I had to order the coffee. It shouldn't be so good. It has that little smell of coffee from the service station. I was joking, the coffee at the autogrill is much better. This is certainly terrible.
