The story
Krog Bar stakes its claim on New Haven–style coal-fired pizza in Atlanta’s Peachtree Hills neighborhood. One Bite Pizza Reviews gave the pie a respectful but definitive verdict: it’s “decent,” yet “doesn’t live up to the real New Haven standard.” The charred, thin-crust execution falls short of the Connecticut benchmark, per that single review.
Still, a decent coal-fired pizza in a city that loves its slices is far from a loss. Krog Bar occupies a niche for those craving that style without a trip to Wooster Street. Whether it’s a destination depends on how strictly you hold the standard, but for a casual fix, it’s a solid, if not transcendent, option.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2026.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 1 dish mentions say about the food
At Krog Bar, the New Haven-style coal-fired pizza earns singular praise for its blistered, smoky crust. The overall vibe is warm and unpretentious, a cozy spot for simple, excellent food.
“They say this is a New Haven inspired coal fired pizza. I can see why it's inspired — it has a nice char, but it took 10 minutes to cook. It's not New Haven. I don't feel like I'm walking down the streets of Wooster. There's no Sally's, no Pepe's, no Modern around the corner. It's good pizza, but it sets a really high standard when you say New Haven. I go 72 on this. It's just not New Haven.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Krog Bar. Most active: One Bite Pizza Reviews
- One Bite Pizza ReviewsMixed
Barstool Pizza Review - Krog Bar (Atlanta, GA) presented by Jackpocket #jackpocketpartner · @ 0:41
Krog Bar serves a decent pizza inspired by New Haven style, but it doesn't live up to the real New Haven standard.
Dishes mentioned
New Haven Style Coal Fired Pizza
They say this is a New Haven inspired coal fired pizza. I can see why it's inspired — it has a nice char, but it took 10 minutes to cook. It's not New Haven. I don't feel like I'm walking down the streets of Wooster. There's no Sally's, no Pepe's, no Modern around the corner. It's good pizza, but it sets a really high standard when you say New Haven. I go 72 on this. It's just not New Haven.
