What diners say
Synthesized from 37 Google reviews · tap an aspect for the detail
Diners consistently praise the enchanting, tranquil setting within a historic monastery courtyard and the high quality, creative cuisine that balances tradition with innovation. Many highlight the passion of the chef and the attentive, knowledgeable service, making it a memorable stop along the Via Francigena. While most find the tasting menus well-priced for the experience, a recurring note is that the fixed menu format and simple presentations may not suit everyone, and some feel the value is better for the lower-priced options.
Location & Ambiance
The restaurant's setting in a charming, historic courtyard next to a church is repeatedly described as magical, peaceful, and unforgettable. Guests love the rustic yet modern decor and the outdoor seating, which harmonizes beautifully with the surrounding medieval village.
Food Quality & Creativity
The cuisine is widely celebrated for its excellent ingredients, bold flavors, and creative twists on Tuscan classics. Dishes like the green onions from the garden, the pork, and the turnip and Gorgonzola pie receive special mentions. The tasting menus are praised for their balance and generous portions.
Service & Hospitality
The staff, particularly Nicola in the dining room and Samuele in the kitchen, are frequently commended for their warmth, professionalism, and passion. Guests appreciate the detailed explanations of each course and the attentive, personalized service.
Value & Pricing
Many diners find the quality-to-price ratio excellent, especially for the 35€ menu, which is considered a great deal. However, some feel the higher-priced menus and certain dishes (like the cheese plate) are overpriced given their simplicity. The fixed menu format is a point of contention for those who prefer à la carte.
Menu Format & Flexibility
The restaurant offers only fixed tasting menus, which some guests find limiting. While the menus are well-curated and change weekly, a few reviewers wish for more choice or the option to order individual dishes. This format is generally accepted as part of the experience.
Atmosphere & Comfort
The interior is described as modern yet in harmony with the historic setting, though a few find it a bit sparse or cold. Overall, the ambiance is considered cozy and welcoming, with a lovely courtyard for summer dining.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 28 dish mentions say about the food
Reviewers consistently praise the Pecorino sardo 4 mesi, calling it a standout, while the overall vibe is one of rustic, heartfelt simplicity that elevates humble ingredients into something memorable.
“Before dessert, a slice of cheese — Sardinian pecorino, 4 months aged. A nice pecorino, quite soft, with a slight spiciness on the tongue. With such a short aging, it hasn't brought out huge flavours or aromas, but it's nice to lead into dessert.”
“Before dessert, a slice of cheese — Sardinian pecorino, 4 months aged. A nice pecorino, quite soft, with a slight spiciness on the tongue. With such a short aging, it hasn't brought out huge flavours or aromas, but it's nice to lead into dessert.”
“Before dessert, a slice of cheese — Sardinian pecorino, 4 months aged. A nice pecorino, quite soft, with a slight spiciness on the tongue. With such a short aging, it hasn't brought out huge flavours or aromas, but it's nice to lead into dessert.”
“Before dessert, a slice of cheese — Sardinian pecorino, 4 months aged. A nice pecorino, quite soft, with a slight spiciness on the tongue. With such a short aging, it hasn't brought out huge flavours or aromas, but it's nice to lead into dessert.”
What creators say
4 creators have covered Futura Osteria di Abbadia Isola. Most active: Francesco Zini
Futura Osteria is a hidden gem in the tiny village of Abbadia Isola, serving simple, genuine dishes with a focus on short supply chains and seasonal ingredients — I'd come back for a three-course menu, especially in winter.
Dishes mentioned
Capponata con Stracciatella
I start with a capponata — a Sicilian dish with stracciatella on top. It's a cold course, very rich in umami from the tomato, pine nuts, and creamy eggplant. The stracciatella boosts it even more. A very indulgent start.
Pita con Guacamole e Scamerita di Cinta Senese
Next, a pita bread with guacamole — avocado, onion, and other bits — and inside, scamerita di cinta senese, so fat on fat. The pita is heated, the topping is fresh. The meat is very savoury, tender, cooked for many hours, almost the same consistency as the avocado. Maybe slightly too chewy, but I love it as an appetizer. I could make this at home.
Insalata di Couscous con Verdure
A couscous salad with vegetables — zucchini, carrots, bell pepper, and lemon. For a course in a seven-course menu, it's quite generous. Very fresh. The lemon gives an extra boost of freshness, but the protagonist is the oil — it has a nice bitter, raspy finish in the throat, very pleasant with all the vegetables.
Spaghetto alla Vedova con Gota
The second primo: spaghetto alla vedova. 'Vedova' is a condiment from Southern Italy — tomato and cheese, called 'widow' because it lacks meat. Here there is meat: gota, which is becoming a Slow Food presidium in this area. Tomato, gota, a battuto of garlic and parsley, and fennel seeds. Spaghetto from Pastificio Martelli. You can really taste the parsley — it reminds me of spaghetti alle vongole or seafood spaghetti. Even though the ingredients seem heavy, it's very delicate and refreshing as a pasta. There's a nice little 'scrigno' of gota left. Of course, I do the scarpetta.
Tartare di Manzo con Cruditè di Verdure
Second course: beef tartare with a crudité of vegetables. The tartare has an excellent flavour, left almost pure. Very simple, the meat is very tender. All enriched by little sauces with a mayonnaise base and tomatoes. The vegetables are from the garden, picked this morning. A great little tartare. I'm not sure if the portion is the same as the three-course menu — the tartare is as big as Anita's — but the pita and spaghetti were smaller.
- Francesco ZiniLoved
Una TRATTORIA nascosta con menù degustazione da 7 portate · @ 1:42
A hidden osteria in a tiny Tuscan village, serving simple, high-quality dishes with a focus on local ingredients and a weekly-changing menu; I'd return for a smaller tasting menu or a casual lunch.
Dishes mentioned
Capponata con Stracciatella
I start with a capponata — a Sicilian dish with stracciatella on top. It's a cold course, very rich in umami from the tomato, pine nuts, and creamy eggplant. The stracciatella boosts it even more. A very indulgent start.
Pita con Guacamole e Scamerita di Cinta Senese
Next, a pita bread with guacamole — avocado, onion, and other bits — and inside, scamerita di cinta senese, so fat on fat. The pita is heated, the topping is fresh. The meat is very savoury, tender, cooked for many hours, almost the same consistency as the avocado. Maybe slightly too chewy, but I love it as an appetizer. I could make this at home.
Insalata di Couscous con Verdure
A couscous salad with vegetables — zucchini, carrots, bell pepper, and lemon. For a course in a seven-course menu, it's quite generous. Very fresh. The lemon gives an extra boost of freshness, but the protagonist is the oil — it has a nice bitter, raspy finish in the throat, very pleasant with all the vegetables.
Spaghetto alla Vedova con Gota
The second primo: spaghetto alla vedova. 'Vedova' is a condiment from Southern Italy — tomato and cheese, called 'widow' because it lacks meat. Here there is meat: gota, which is becoming a Slow Food presidium in this area. Tomato, gota, a battuto of garlic and parsley, and fennel seeds. Spaghetto from Pastificio Martelli. You can really taste the parsley — it reminds me of spaghetti alle vongole or seafood spaghetti. Even though the ingredients seem heavy, it's very delicate and refreshing as a pasta. There's a nice little 'scrigno' of gota left. Of course, I do the scarpetta.
- Tartar di Manzo con Crudité di Verdure
- Francesco ZiniLoved
Una TRATTORIA nascosta con menù degustazione da 7 portate · @ 01:40
- Francesco ZiniLoved
Una TRATTORIA nascosta con menù degustazione da 7 portate · @ 00:20
Dishes mentioned
- Capponata
- Pane pita con guacamole e scamerita di cinta senese
- Insalata di couscous
- Spaghetto alla vedova con gota
- Tartar di manzo con crudité di verdure
