The story
Tucked away on Irving Place, Caffè Panna has earned its 4.5-star reputation as an ice cream shop that reimagines the Italian affogato. As Insider Food noted, the shop "reinvents the classic Italian affogato with creative toppings and mix-ins, offering a variety of textures and flavors" — a promise that draws steady crowds.
Signature offerings include a classic Affogato, the more indulgent Affogato Sundae, and a Fresh Mint Crema that showcases the kitchen’s attention to bright, complementary flavors. With its casual, neighborhood-friendly vibe and Italian-gelateria roots, Caffè Panna has quickly become a local fixture for anyone craving a thoughtful, textural twist on a beloved treat.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2019.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 3 dish mentions say about the food
The affogato steals the show, a perfect marriage of hot espresso and cold, silky gelato. The overall vibe is one of simple, joyful indulgence, making every bite feel like a small celebration.
“I get the punch of espresso with the melting ice cream. It's like a creamier, soupier coffee with a caramel undertone. The ice cream melts away quickly, and I really enjoy that. I like it.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Caffè Panna. Most active: Insider Food
Caffè Panna is a New York City ice cream shop that reinvents the classic Italian affogato with creative toppings and mix-ins, offering a variety of textures and flavors.
Dishes mentioned
Affogato
I get the punch of espresso with the melting ice cream. It's like a creamier, soupier coffee with a caramel undertone. The ice cream melts away quickly, and I really enjoy that. I like it.
Affogato Sundae
I scoop it up to get all the elements. I like how the hot and cold, sweet and crunchy complement each other. The coffee doesn't feel bitter and the ice cream doesn't feel too sweet. I really like the combination.
Fresh Mint Crema
This is a thicker cream with fresh mint and a crunch element, topped with a shot of espresso. It's not like regular peppermint ice cream with fudge. I scoop it up to get the full experience.
