The story
Tucked away on a tiny West Village block, 4 Charles Prime Rib is a notoriously hard-to-reserve steakhouse where the payoff is as much about the food as the triumph of snagging a seat. With intimate counter seating and an old-school upscale vibe, the venue rewards those who get through the door. Creator Jack’s Dining Room calls the Wagyu Smash Burger “incredible,” ranking it among the best burgers he’s ever had—and that alone justifies the hype.
Beyond the burger, Jack’s Dining Room also praises the “incredible” Prime Rib sandwich and the truffle mac and cheese. His one reservation: the $75 garlic rosemary lamb chops, while good, simply aren’t worth the price. For anyone lucky enough to land a reservation, the burger and sandwich make the effort worthwhile.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2024.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 4 dish mentions say about the food
The prime rib sandwich is the undisputed star, a decadent, towering indulgence. The overall vibe is one of nostalgic, unapologetic excess, delivering pure comfort with every bite.
“This $40 Prime Rib sandwich comes with a homemade aioli and a side of horseradish. I personally hate horseradish, but the guy was like you gotta try it, it's really good — I don't even like horseradish but this is amazing. And the jus is just that simmered-down beef bath. I'm not gonna lie, they're two for two.”
What creators say
2 creators have covered 4 Charles Prime Rib. Most active: Jack's Dining Room